Aggregating multiple probability intervals to improve calibration

We apply the principles of the “wisdom of crowds (woc)” to improve the calibration of interval estimates. previous research has documented the significant impact of the woc on the accuracy of point estimates but only a few studies have examined its effectiveness in aggregating interval estimates. we demonstrate that collective probability intervals obtained by several heuristics can reduce the typical overconfidence of the individual estimates. we re-analyzed data from glaser,langer and weber (2013) and from soll and klayman (2004) and applied four heuristics averaging,median,enveloping,probability averaging-suggested by gaba,tsetlin and winkler (2014) and new heuristics,averaging with trimming and quartiles. we used the hit rate and themean squared error (mse) to evaluate the quality of the methods. all methods reduced miscalibration to some degree,and quartiles was the most beneficial securing accuracy and informativeness. © 2015. the authors license.