>
Fa   |   Ar   |   En
   coincident objects and the grounding problem  
   
نویسنده - -
منبع پژوهش هاي فلسفي - 1401 - دوره : 16 - شماره : 41 - صفحه:164 -173
چکیده    Pluralists believe in the occurrence of numerically distinct spatiotemporally coincident objects. they argue that there are coincident objects that share all physical and spatiotemporal properties and relations; nevertheless, they differ in terms of modal and some other profiles. appealing to the grounding problem according to which nothing can ground the modal differences between coincident objects, monists reject the occurrence of coincident objects. in the first part of this paper, i attempt to show that the dispute between monists and pluralists cannot be settled based upon the grounding problem tout court. i argue that the grounding problem or a very similar problem is a challenge for all monists and pluralists alike if they are ontologically committed to the existence of composite objects as independent entities. in the final part, adopting the aristotelian account of essence, i propose a solution that enables pluralists to plausibly ground modal differences between coincident objects.
کلیدواژه coincident objects ,the grounding problem ,essence ,modality ,material objects
آدرس saint louis university, usa
پست الکترونیکی ataollah.hashemi@slu.edu
 
     
   
Authors
  
 
 

Copyright 2023
Islamic World Science Citation Center
All Rights Reserved