Asad Zaman: Crisis in Islamic economics: Diagnosis and prescription

On reading through the paper by asad zaman one gets the impression of an irreconcilable gap between a misconceived western intellection and an ideal islamic reemergence. yet it presents a utopia world that did not exist even during the time of the prophet,for the prophet did not cast away what is discernibly good and true in pre-islamic belief. on the other hand,mankind did not cast away the great message of islam. there is intellectual exchange between the old and new ideas. on such recognition of truth about islam by the ever-present bestowing of consciousness wrote carlyle (undated)(2): a noble book (qur'an); all men's book! it is our first,oldest statement of the neverending problem,-- man's destiny,and god's ways with him in this earth.